| Catocala (Catocala) nupta Linnaeus, 1767 | Red Underwing |
| Catocala (Mormonia) epione Drury, 1773 | Epione Underwing |
| Catocala (Mormonia) herodias Strecker, 1876 | Gerhard's underwing |
| Catocala agrippina Strecker, 1874 | Agrippina Underwing |
| Catocala alabamae Grote, 1875 | Alabama Underwing |
| Catocala amatrix Hübner, 1813 | Sweetheart Underwing |
| Catocala amestris Strecker, 1874 | The Leadplant Underwing Moth |
| Catocala amica Hübner, 1818 | Cape sole |
| Catocala andromedae Guenée, 1852 | Andromeda Underwing |
| Catocala angusi Grote, 1876 | Angus underwing |
| Catocala blandula Hulst, 1884 | Charming Underwing |
| Catocala cara Guenée, 1852 | Bronze Underwing |
| Catocala carissima (Hulst, 1880) | ⇒ Catocala cara Guenée, 1852 |
| Catocala cerogama Guenée, 1852 | Yellow Banded Underwing |
| Catocala clintonii Grote, 1865 | Clinton's underwing |
| Catocala coccinata Grote, 1872 | Scarlet Underwing |
| Catocala concubens Walker, 1858 | |
| Catocala concumbens Walker, 1857 | Desert milkweed |
| Catocala connubialis Guenée, 1852 | Connubial Underwing |
| Catocala consors Smith, 1797 | Consort Underwing |
| Catocala crataegi Saunders, 1876 | Chokeberry Underwing |
| Catocala dejecta Strecker, 1880 | Dejected Underwing |
| Catocala delilah Strecker, 1874 | Channel flounder |
| Catocala flebilis Grote, 1872 | Mournful Underwing |
| Catocala gracilis W.H. Edwards, 1864 | Graceful Underwing |
| Catocala grynea Cramer, 1782 | Woody Underwing |
| Catocala habilis Grote, 1872 | Habilis Underwing |
| Catocala ilia Cramer, 1779 | Beloved Underwing |
| Catocala illecta Walker, 1857 | Magdalen Underwing |
| Catocala innubens Guenée, 1852 | Betrothed Underwing |
| Catocala insolabilis Guenée, 1852 | Inconsolable Underwing |
| Catocala jair Strecker, 1897 | Barrens Underwing |
| Catocala judith Strecker, 1874 | Channel flounder |
| Catocala junctura Walker, 1857 | Catocala arizonae |
| Catocala lacrymosa Guenée, 1852 | Tearful Underwing |
| Catocala lincolnana A.E. Brower, 1976 | Lincoln Underwing |
| Catocala lineella Grote, 1872 | Girlfriend Underwing |
| Catocala luctuosa (Grote, 1872) | ⇒ Catocala retecta Grote, 1872 |
| Catocala maestosa Hulst, 1884 | Sad Underwing |
| Catocala marmorata W.H. Edwards, 1864 | Marbled Underwing |
| Catocala messalina Guenée, 1852 | Messalina Underwing |
| Catocala micronympha Guenée, 1852 | Little Bride |
| Catocala minuta W.H. Edwards, 1864 | Little Underwing |
| Catocala mira Grote, 1876 | Wonderful Underwing |
| Catocala muliercula Guenée, 1852 | Little Wife Underwing |
| Catocala myristica | |
| Catocala nebulosa W.H. Edwards, 1864 | Clouded Underwing |
| Catocala neogama Smith, 1797 | Bride underwing |
| Catocala nuptialis (Walker, 1857) | ⇒ Catocala nupta Linnaeus, 1767 |
| Catocala obscura Strecker, 1873 | Finescale triggerfish |
| Catocala orba Kusnetzov, 1903 | Orb Underwing |
| Catocala palaeogama Guenée, 1852 | Old Wife Underwing |
| Catocala piatrix Grote, 1864 | Penitent Underwing |
| Catocala praeclara Grote & Robi..., 1866 | Praeclara Underwing |
| Catocala pretiosa Lintner, 1876 | Precious Underwing |
| Catocala residua Grote, 1874 | Residua Underwing |
| Catocala retecta Grote, 1872 | The Yellow-Gray Underwing |
| Catocala robinsonii Grote, 1872 | Robinson's Underwing |
| Catocala sappho Strecker, 1874 | Channel flounder |
| Catocala serena Edwards, 1864 | Serene Underwing |
| Catocala similis W.H. Edwards, 1864 | Similar Underwing |
| Catocala subnata Grote, 1864 | Dab |
| Catocala ulalume Strecker, 1878 | Ulalume Underwing |
| Catocala ultronia Hübner, 1818 | Catocala plum |
| Catocala unijuga Walker, 1858 | Once-married Underwing |
| Catocala vidua Smith, 1797 | The Widow |
| Catocala whitneyi Dodge, 1874 | Whitney's Underwing |
